February 18, 2009 | In: Uncategorized
It’s Time to Start Assigning Video Essays
Writing papers is an important part of higher education. I should know. In my MBA program, each course has weekly papers that I have to write. This is understandable. Writing papers is the best way for the professors to gauge whether we understand the material taught and are able to use it in case analysis. I suggest, however, that there is a better way.
Writing essays helps us fine-tune our writing skills and more importantly, conveys our knowledge of a subject. How many papers, however, do I have to write for professors to be confident in my ability to write? The real reason I have to continue to write papers is because this is the only way for the professor to give their critique on my ability to use the information taught. That is, until now.
This is 2009. Professors should be utilizing the video revolution taking place on the web. Instead of having a paper due a week, have each student give a two minute video on their opinion for the assignment. It takes less time to create than a paper. It takes less time to critique. And most importantly, it requires students to communicate their opinion verbally. I’ve sadly met brilliant people who were not able to communicate effectively. Sure, they could write a hell of a paper, but who cares. We need a new focus of education on verbal communication. This is one small step that will not only improve education, but also improve the quality of students coming out of graduate programs.
4 Responses to It’s Time to Start Assigning Video Essays
Josef
February 18th, 2009 at 4:28 am
Wow…I totally and completely disagree. There are far too many people in the business world who can’t write a coherent letter, memo, or business plan. I’ve seen sales documents that looked like they were put together by Fifth-graders; I’ve seen analyses that were beyond awful. While verbal skills are key and should ALSO be developed, I think we’d find ourselves in a far worse position if videos replaced effective writing.
Ely Rosenstock
February 18th, 2009 at 4:33 am
@Josef
I’m not saying we get rid of the written assignments. I just think that a balance would be valuable. I’m in my last semester in graduate school. I must have written over 100 papers for this MBA. I think, if I couldn’t write, I wouldn’t have made it this far. And while my presentation skills are tested often, my verbal communication skills have not been tested nearly as much.
jonny goldstein
February 18th, 2009 at 1:20 pm
Not a bad idea to mix it up a little.
Barry
February 18th, 2009 at 6:26 pm
Agreed on a balanced presentation approach – in real life, you need to know how to present a concept/product/service via paper, presentation, phone conference, in person, etc. Business school should account and train for all formats.